One thing I encounter consistently and frequently, from undergrads right up to PhD students, is general confusion about properly referencing source material. Whether it be an assignment, conference presentation, or term paper – students repeatedly present photos, graphs, tables, prose, and concepts painstakingly collected and/or developed by others, with absolutely no acknowledgements to the people who actually own that intellectual property. These students don’t (all) intentionally plagiarise, they just don’t seem to realize that copying the thoughts, ideas, or products of someone else’s efforts actually constitutes plagiarism. So if you’re a college or university student, read on and learn how to get it right…
What constitutes plagiarism? Here’s what my own employer, the University of Alberta, says under section 30.3.2(1) of the Code of Student Behaviour:
“No Student shall submit the words, ideas, images or data of another person as the Student’s own in any academic writing, essay, thesis, project, assignment, presentation or poster in a course or program of study.”
This seems pretty clear to me but for some reason students seem to be completely baffled by it. So over the years I’ve developed my own explanation for the students:
“If you didn’t invent/create it and you weren’t born knowing it – then you MUST reference it.”
Specifically, if you don’t reference it, then you are claiming it as your own and that is plagiarism.
Here below are some common examples of where referencing is required – ones that students commonly forget (or don’t bother to) reference properly. The most common justifications typically offered by students follow in brackets.
- Paraphrased information (“…but I wasn’t’ quoting him, just summarizing.”)
- Graphs (“I didn’t know plagiarism included graphs.”)
- Photos (“…but they were on the web!”)
Let me reiterate – if you didn’t create it and you weren’t born knowing it, then you must reference it. Otherwise, it is plagiarism and that is an academic office. It doesn’t need to be a quote – even ideas are intellectual property. Depending upon the severity of the case – the following penalties can be expected for plagiarism:
- Zero on the assignment or project
- Failure in the course
- Dean’s holiday (i.e. expulsion for up to a year)
- Expulsion forever
- Rescindment of your degree (Yes, you can be punished for plagiarism retroactively!)
Most cases of plagiarism that I encounter stem from ignorance of what constitutes plagiarism and/or laziness about keeping track of sources. If this describes your situation, then today is the day to change all that. Here are some examples to help you get started.
- If you use a quote from a textbook or paraphrase some comments from an article – cite the author(s) and year of publication and provide the full reference citation in a list of references at the end of your assignment, paper, presentation, or poster.
- Before you use someone else’s photograph, graph or table in your thesis, conference presentation or poster, report, or scholarly paper – you must first ask for and obtain written permission and you must also acknowledge the source where it appears in your document. You don’t usually need to obtain written permission to use these items in a course assignment, project, or presentation – but you do still need to cite the source and provide details in a proper list of references at the end.
- The original source of any equations you present or use must also be cited and referenced.
What about stuff you get off the web? Well, my response would be to ask you, “What the heck are you doing getting your scholarly material off the web?” Anyone can post any manner of nonsense on the web – that doesn’t make it fact. Your sources should be genuine, peer-reviewed academic papers, textbooks, reports, and theses. The only exception to this that comes to mind is that you may be presenting data from a government website; in that case you should provide the web link right with the cited data (it doesn’t go in the list of references). Other than that, I would suggest you avoid using the web for reference material – graduate students in particular: you’re not going to impress anybody by surfing the web instead of the library for your source material.
What do you do if your source is a paper, graph or concept cited by another author (not the original author)? This commonly happens when using textbooks and journal papers as reference material. The scholarly thing to do it to go and look up the original reference – yes, it takes time – but the truth is, just reading about it in a subsequent summary is seldom enough to understand it adequately (especially if you are a graduate student writing a paper or thesis). In fact, many people interpret things incorrectly (or with a small measure of personal bias) and if you don’t go back to the original reference, you may end up perpetuating an erroneous interpretation of that original work. So, you must always make the effort to try to find the original reference. In some (generally rare) cases, it’s just not possible to read/find the original reference. Perhaps it’s in another language, or possibly it’s an obscure government report that is just not available to you. If you absolutely cannot find the original reference, then you would typically handle it as follows: cite the original reference, then say “…as reported in…” and then cite the reference you are actually using. This at least lets people know that the information you’re presenting is ‘third-hand’. Note also that both references must appear in your list of references.
No question, referencing is a tedious business – but it doesn’t have to be time consuming if you’re organized. Specifically, if you take a moment to note down all the details of each reference as you find and use it, it really isn’t all that much work. If you get sloppy about it and have to go back and find stuff a second time to ensure proper source referencing, it can be a real pain and it’s really not the most effective use of your time.
One last reminder – proper referencing has two components – the source citation and the detailed references. The source citation (authors(s) and year of publication) appears with the material you are referencing. The detailed reference goes at the end of your report, presentation, or poster in a proper List of References. To see what I mean by a List of References – and to see the type and form of information to present – look at the end of any journal paper as an example.
Hope you found this helpful – have a great week! 🙂